WASHINGTON (AP) — President Joe Biden this past week found himself in search of a foreign policy sweet spot: somewhere between pulling a screeching U-turn on four years of Trumpism and cautiously approaching the world as it is.
In recent days, Biden has piled new sanctions on Russia, announced he would withdraw all US troops from Afghanistan in less than five months and backed away from a campaign promise to sharply raise refugee admission caps.
“You know, we'll be much more formidable to our adversaries and competitors over the long term if we fight the battles for the next 20 years, not the last 20,” Biden said in an explanation of his decision to withdraw troops from Afghanistan that also summed up his topline foreign policy hopes.
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=8d766012-5560-48b3-aa83-a3d61c5ecae7
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=eae38aef-d7d6-40c4-86c8-699a12b99de9
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=2839a340-8155-447b-b60e-e020d6b664fe
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=02700d76-10a4-499c-803a-1bbeaff4016c
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=22af979d-81c1-411f-98db-d6606e6a6ff4
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=bcc9e134-a5d8-40bb-9925-f10bd8fee27e
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=90e63d24-ae99-4312-bedc-0e8ecf6f7c17
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=e95ab120-e358-4165-abfd-f7750af38b48
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=96ebc476-09d3-4108-9365-4d14ba10ce93
On foreign policy decisions, Biden faces drag of pragmatism
Yet, as this past week has shown, Biden is finding that when it comes to the painstaking process of statecraft, the drag of pragmatism can slow the sprint toward big-picture aspirations.
First there was Biden’s announcement that he would end the “forever war” in Afghanistan by the 20th anniversary of the Sept. 11 attacks on the U.S. that triggered America’s longest conflict.
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=9ca11144-b5c4-4b64-a4e6-c1aec79e4e44
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=b3d321fe-4005-4d1f-afdf-97adab515e88
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=376e3fc5-de9f-45be-af9a-2355f3c2d730
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=83b86f62-d014-4aca-92ff-c9651425c329
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=3cd6b513-4833-4836-b2d6-0c44ad02e23e
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=f5d25116-a236-41be-a814-a23e193ec658
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=cd298c1d-6fe7-4a85-925d-b36493205aab
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=c40253ee-9d64-4829-b246-1da7dfb85465
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=aee99423-3d1c-4924-81f1-12919eda6e4e
Biden, long a skeptic of the U.S. strategy in Afghanistan, is setting out to do what his last three predecessors vowed to accomplish but were never able to deliver.
Biden campaigned on the promise to end the war — and former President Donald Trump set a May 1 deadline to do just that. In the end, though, Biden said he’ll get Americans out, but he won’t beat a “hasty” retreat under his predecessor’s timeline. Instead, he called for a monthslong exit ramp even as Republicans — and a few Democrats — criticized the withdrawal as ill-advised.
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=25884517-5d7b-40b9-863e-6953ec135b44
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=50ec197a-f648-4618-9c25-4f57b7cea9f0
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=218cf0f8-c814-4cf0-9066-9ba5a619a7b7
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=9f461e5f-faf8-42d4-9bba-4728ccafd3f5
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=2fce8cc8-ee3b-41e0-9f6b-b0623c08067d
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=9f25a927-97f8-459a-b408-bebc868167de
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=d3dcea40-885e-48f4-8769-c30a95b2294e
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=4c81f0a0-0cdc-48f2-8679-41eb55ac29c8
Lisa Curtis, who served as National Security Council senior director for South and Central Asia in the Trump administration, said lost in Biden’s desire to end the war this year is that the U.S. had effectively right-sized the American presence with roughly 2,500 troops. It’s not cheap, she noted, but it’s a relatively modest cost to prevent Afghanistan from again becoming a terrorist safe haven.
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=6c396aa0-a01f-4f66-be35-db612c0126a5
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=5ceacd0e-4645-4cb7-9721-37809951087c
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=68dede5f-013d-4602-a32f-001e1fbe2cff
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=db0ebdd6-87c8-47a7-9672-01955a69d0d9
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=d424f351-fe80-415e-ac3c-8b7b1b92e4b0
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=239c64bf-bf3e-4bcf-97a2-403e1acc7144
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=9709f40a-cb30-426c-8eda-ca8d96688b26
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=13a557c1-4be5-40bb-b62b-0aa2e0a22700
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=20eefc12-c455-440a-ab65-8cf74f81c965
It’s been more than a year since an American service member has been killed in combat in Afghanistan. Curtis argued that with the relatively modest troop presence, the U.S. could maintain a crucial intelligence foothold in a dangerous part of the world, something that Biden’s CIA director, William Burns, acknowledged could be diminished by the planned U.S. withdrawal.
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=565ef79f-5ab9-4c49-a0b7-036c67eb2d2d
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=f0f7838c-063a-483e-ba7a-d58007c09403
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=c1b011ae-2aa4-4bee-b2ff-6c737e5a525f
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=e9c1dbdf-5808-414a-acbc-8e77167623c6
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=f7df0faa-33e2-4976-b409-4faf1962c721
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=a9198913-6682-4425-989d-cb40e7302c40
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=09e01de5-3fdb-486e-93b3-41ca58073b42
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=c04799b2-06f9-40f6-9279-f02f66d9aae8
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=c745930c-8afb-42de-b7b1-8b678c144b9a
Biden’s push-pull calibrations were also evident this past week in his approach to Russia.
The president levied new sanctions on Moscow for cyberattacks and interference in the 2020 election, expelling 10 Russian diplomats and targeting Moscow’s ability to borrow money by prohibiting U.S. financial institutions from buying Russian bonds.
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=985f4d85-2889-4446-a016-2f2b27b07d72
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=c614b403-a8ab-41e8-8eca-1bf99dc3d542
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=987aeacb-1711-419d-9240-5cca1baa74bd
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=77f3c633-a11f-4202-93cf-dc17af2c67c3
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=c911fdfd-8d7e-422a-8e89-fb505774fea0
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=909d022b-b759-4ec5-98af-af8a2fefb38b
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=acd1bad3-9005-4e82-bd4f-a48081d4c742
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=c79db800-7ea0-4918-a808-69ce8da93178
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=b674825c-0bd4-4c4a-9c12-c7590b142daa
But Biden, who in February had declared an end to the days of the U.S. “rolling over” to Vladimir Putin, simultaneously suggested that he was getting tough on the Russian president and asserted that he wants a “stable, predictable” relationship with him. The president also suggested a summer summit with Putin.
Biden said he made clear to Putin during a phone call on Tuesday, two days before the sanctions were publicly announced, that he could have been much tougher on the Russians.
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=35117b20-6b42-4646-81b6-5e760046b828
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=3d5a26f9-8345-4e46-b72f-63b0031e6dc1
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=b45c97bc-891d-4517-adbb-c8633b2c71af
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=3e0ec6a0-c80e-41da-95fd-c07ff30a3827
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=174ae37f-59fd-4f82-89ff-97c745c62be0
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=b4b173c6-0dfc-44ac-ac54-8d39345eed9b
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=3ed169ab-82df-45df-ab2e-6579730b27e7
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=90350a86-122b-4d61-a270-eabf32a55d03
“I was clear with President Putin that we could have gone further, but I chose not to do so,” Biden said. “I chose to be proportionate.”
The past week also brought new steps from Biden on refugee admissions that showed the administration’s efforts to navigate the fraught politics of the issue. The president issued an emergency declaration stating that the limit of 15,000 refugee admissions set by Trump for this year “remains justified by humanitarian concerns and is otherwise in the national interest.”
The move marked a dramatic departure from Biden’s campaign promise to raise the refugee limit to 125,000 and then to at least 95,000 annually after that. It came as the Biden administration is struggling to deal with a sharp increase in unaccompanied young migrants from El Salvador, Guatemala and Honduras arriving at the border.
After an avalanche of criticism from Democratic lawmakers, the White House within hours made a quick course correction on Friday. It said Biden next month would increase the historically low cap on refugees set by Trump — but probably not even to the 62,500 level that was in a plan submitted to Congress in February. The number actually admitted is expected to be closer to 15,000.
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=77b06342-91bb-4f22-8032-d272c125dc10
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=6820693f-acf6-49fe-aeb9-bc431f11d44d
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=c6b2f9e7-802c-4d16-896a-ce87e6faa71a
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=794acd1b-8a60-4453-8e8a-d78955651be0
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=8814a921-f4d9-40ec-a014-571611ff5b11
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=81ba1e48-1092-4162-9405-b59db74fe3a2
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=2d9914f7-815c-4535-b8ec-9c6479e2995a
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=13935f1f-5394-4e2d-bd7d-d5757699b2f1
https://www.nsacct.org/nsacctwww/network/members/profile?UserKey=04a8f828-d243-4e39-9131-356f0bc4359f
Before the Biden administration did its walk-back, Stephen Miller, the architect of Trump’s hard-line immigration policies, cheered Biden’s move in a tweet that laid bare the political ramifications of the issue.
“This reflects Team Biden’s awareness that the border flood will cause record midterm losses (asterisk)if(asterisk) GOP keeps issue front & center,” Miller tweeted.
Biden over the years has displayed a willingness to cut against his party’s grain at times on foreign policy matters. As vice president, he frequently found himself out of sync with some of President Barack Obama’s foreign policy advisers.
https://niche4k.blogspot.com/2021/04/joe-biden-on-foreign-policy-decisions.html
https://thehealthcareblog.com/blog/author/JoeBidenOnforeign/
https://www.atoallinks.com/2021/about-joe-biden-and-foreign-policy-decisions/
https://hire.careerbliss.com/company/about-president-joe-biden-and-foreign-policy-decisions/
Former Defense Secretary Robert Gates, in his memoir, wrote that Biden had been “wrong on nearly every major foreign policy and national security issue over the past four decades.” Early in Obama’s tenure, Gen. Stanley McCrystal publicly suggested Biden was “shortsighted” in urging the president to focus on a smaller counterterrorism effort in Afghanistan while military leaders were urging a troop buildup.
As Biden looks to lay down his own markers on foreign policy in the opening months of his presidency, others in Obama world say the president and his team have shown an ambitious reach in the early going.
Michael McFaul, who served as U.S. ambassador to Russia during the Obama years, credits Biden’s team for taking a unique step by issuing interim national security strategic guidance in March, months before the administration was required to do so. The early guidance sent a message around the globe that they’re serious about breaking from the past four years, McFaul said.
“They have a much bigger ambition for their foreign policy,” said McFaul, now director at the Freeman Spogli Institute for International Studies at Stanford University. “I cannot think of an administration that has ever done that before.”
